Skinn

Ingredients

Pore-Clogging Ingredients List: What to Check and Why

Ingredients most often listed as pore-clogging include isopropyl myristate, coconut oil, cocoa butter, and acetylated lanolin. The ratings come from old tests, so use them as a guide.

Last reviewed

The Glow angle

Glow scans a product barcode and flags comedogenic and pore-clogging ingredients, along with fragrance, preservatives, and common allergens. You can see where a flagged ingredient sits in the list, which tells you more than the rating alone. The 0-100 safety score covers the whole formula. Glow does not diagnose acne, so persistent or painful breakouts need a dermatologist.

The pore-clogging ingredients list, in short

A pore-clogging ingredients list names the cosmetic ingredients most often linked to comedones, the small bumps that come before blackheads and whiteheads. The names that come up again and again are isopropyl myristate, isopropyl palmitate, coconut oil, cocoa butter, acetylated lanolin alcohol, laureth-4, myristyl myristate, wheat germ oil, and algae extracts such as carrageenan.

These lists are useful, but they have real limits. Most of the ratings come from animal tests on raw ingredients, and a finished product can behave very differently. If you want to check a product quickly at the shelf, an ingredient scanner such as Glow can flag comedogenic ingredients on the label for you. This guide explains how the ratings work, where they go wrong, and how to check a product before you buy it.

Where comedogenic ratings come from

Comedogenic ratings started with the rabbit ear test, which researchers used from the 1950s on. They applied a raw ingredient to the inside of a rabbit's ear, waited, and then looked at how much the follicles swelled and filled with keratin. The result was turned into a score.

The lists you see online usually use a scale from 0 to 5. A 0 means the ingredient caused no comedones in the test, and a 5 means it caused many. In 1982, dermatologists Mills and Kligman published a human version of the test that used the skin of the upper back, which is rich in oil glands.

From those tests came the idea of "acne cosmetica," acne caused by what you put on your skin. Dermatologists got lists of substances to avoid for people who break out easily, and those lists still circulate today.

Why the ratings have limits

A review in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology in 1982 already questioned whether the rabbit ear model predicted acne in people. Rabbit ear skin is more sensitive than human facial skin, and its oil glands have a different structure. Labs that tested the same ingredient sometimes got different scores.

The bigger issue is that the tests used raw ingredients, often at full strength. In a 2006 study, dermatologist Zoe Draelos and a colleague tested finished cosmetic products on the backs of people who form comedones easily. Their conclusion was direct: finished products that use comedogenic ingredients are not necessarily comedogenic.

Several things change the real-world effect of an ingredient:

  1. Concentration. An oil at 30 percent of a balm is a very different exposure from the same oil at 1 percent of a serum.
  2. Formula. Other ingredients can change how an oil sits on the skin.
  3. Contact time. A rinse-off cleanser touches skin for seconds, while a night cream stays for hours.
  4. Your skin. People with oily, acne-prone skin react more often than people with dry skin.

A high rating is a reason to look closer. A low rating is reassuring, and your skin still has the final say.

Ingredients most often flagged

These ingredients appear on most comedogenic lists. Scores vary by source, so the groups below matter more than any single number.

Fatty esters

  • Isopropyl myristate
  • Isopropyl palmitate
  • Isopropyl isostearate
  • Myristyl myristate
  • Ethylhexyl palmitate

These are light, slippery emollients used in moisturizers, foundations, and makeup removers. Isopropyl myristate is the classic example and often scores near the top of the scale.

Oils and butters

  • Coconut oil
  • Cocoa butter
  • Wheat germ oil
  • Some heavy plant oils high in oleic acid

Coconut oil is the one people ask about most. It is a popular body and hair oil, and many acne-prone people find it too heavy for the face.

Lanolin derivatives and emulsifiers

  • Acetylated lanolin alcohol
  • Laureth-4
  • Oleth-3 and similar ethoxylated emulsifiers

Other frequent names

  • Algae extract and carrageenan
  • Some D&C red pigments in blush and lipstick
  • Sodium lauryl sulfate, which scores high in some rabbit tests, although it rinses off quickly in most products

Hair products count too. Oils and pomades from your hair can move onto the forehead and hairline. The American Academy of Dermatology notes that oil from hair can cause forehead breakouts, and it suggests washing oily hair more often and keeping it off your face.

What "non-comedogenic" means on a label

"Non-comedogenic" means the brand believes the product will not clog pores. In the United States, no universal standard defines how a brand must test before it uses the term. Some brands test the finished product on people, and others only avoid ingredients from the lists.

The label is still useful. The American Academy of Dermatology recommends that people with acne choose sunscreens and skin care labeled "non-comedogenic" or "won't clog pores." Combine the claim with your own look at the ingredient list for the best result.

How to check a product before you buy

Use these steps for any face product, especially leave-on products.

  1. Find the ingredient list on the box, the bottle, or the brand's website.
  2. Look at the first five to seven ingredients. Ingredients are listed in descending order down to about 1 percent, so these make up most of the formula.
  3. Check those top ingredients against the groups above.
  4. Give leave-on products more attention than cleansers and other rinse-off products.
  5. If a flagged ingredient appears near the end of the list, it is probably present at a low level.
  6. Try one new product at a time for a few weeks, so you can tell what caused a breakout.
  7. Look for a "non-comedogenic" claim as a second check.

How to check pore-clogging ingredients with Glow

Glow does the label work for you, which helps when the list is long or the print is small.

  1. Open Glow and scan the product barcode. Glow checks it against its catalog of more than 35,000 products and Open Beauty Facts.
  2. If the barcode is not found, search for the product by name in the Search tab.
  3. Read the flags. Glow marks comedogenic and pore-clogging ingredients, plus fragrance, preservatives, and common allergens.
  4. Look at the 0-100 safety score for the full formula, and use the flags to decide what matters for your skin.
  5. Scan two or three options in the same aisle and keep the one with the fewest flags in its top ingredients.

Glow checks ingredient lists. It does not diagnose acne or tell you what is causing your breakouts.

When to see a dermatologist, and the bottom line

Ingredient changes help with acne cosmetica, the mild bumps that a product can trigger. They do not treat moderate or severe acne. See a dermatologist if you have painful cysts, scarring, acne that does not improve after a few months of simpler skin care, or bumps that may be something other than acne, such as folliculitis or rosacea.

A pore-clogging ingredients list is a good starting filter. The ingredients that show up most often are fatty esters like isopropyl myristate, heavy oils and butters like coconut oil and cocoa butter, and some lanolin derivatives. Use the ratings to decide which labels to read closely, pay most attention to the top of the list and to leave-on products, and let your own skin's response over a few weeks have the final say.

Ingredients to flag

Glow surfaces these on labels at the shelf.

  • Isopropyl myristate

    A light fatty ester in moisturizers, makeup, and removers. It sits near the top of most comedogenic lists and is the classic example of a pore-clogging emollient.

  • Isopropyl palmitate and isopropyl isostearate

    Close relatives of isopropyl myristate with similar slip and similar high ratings in rabbit ear tests. Look for them in the first few ingredients of leave-on products.

  • Coconut oil (Cocos nucifera oil)

    Rated high on most lists and heavy on oily or acne-prone facial skin. It is often fine on the body, but face use is a common trigger for breakouts.

  • Cocoa butter (Theobroma cacao seed butter)

    A rich butter in balms and body products that most lists rate as moderately to highly comedogenic. It matters most in leave-on face products.

  • Acetylated lanolin alcohol

    A lanolin derivative that scores high in classic comedogenicity tests. Plain lanolin usually scores lower, so check the exact name.

  • Laureth-4 and oleth-3

    Ethoxylated emulsifiers that appear with high scores on many comedogenic lists, especially in creams and makeup bases.

  • Myristyl myristate and ethylhexyl palmitate

    Waxy and oily esters that give a smooth feel to creams and foundations. Both are frequent names on pore-clogging lists.

  • Wheat germ oil

    A heavy plant oil that many lists rate high. It is common in natural and DIY face oils.

  • Algae extract and carrageenan

    Thickeners and marine extracts that some lists rate as comedogenic. The effect depends a lot on concentration and formula.

  • D&C red pigments

    Some red colorants in blush and lip products appear on older comedogenic lists. They are a possible cause of bumps along the cheekbones or around the mouth.

Frequently asked questions

  • The names that appear most often are isopropyl myristate, isopropyl palmitate, coconut oil, cocoa butter, acetylated lanolin alcohol, laureth-4, and wheat germ oil. Their real effect depends on how much is in the product and whether it stays on your skin. Check the first five to seven ingredients of leave-on products first.

  • They are a rough guide. Most ratings come from rabbit ear tests on raw ingredients, and rabbit skin is more sensitive than human facial skin. A 2006 study found that finished products made with comedogenic ingredients are not necessarily comedogenic.

  • No. It means the brand believes the product will not clog pores, and there is no universal standard for the test behind the claim. The label is still a useful filter, and the American Academy of Dermatology suggests that people with acne look for it.

  • Coconut oil rates high on most comedogenic lists, and many people with oily or acne-prone skin break out when they use it on the face. It is often fine on the body or the ends of the hair. Keep it away from the hairline and forehead if you get breakouts there.

  • Yes. Oils, pomades, and leave-in products can move from the hair onto the forehead and hairline. The American Academy of Dermatology notes that oil from hair can cause forehead breakouts. Washing oily hair more often and keeping it off your face can help.

  • Read the first five to seven ingredients and compare them with a pore-clogging ingredients list. An ingredient scanner such as Glow can do this for you from a product barcode. Then try the product alone for a few weeks to see how your skin responds.

Sources

  1. A re-evaluation of the comedogenicity concept · Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology (peer-reviewed), via PubMed
  2. A human model for assessing comedogenic substances · Archives of Dermatology (peer-reviewed), via PubMed
  3. Is the rabbit ear model, in its present state, prophetic of acnegenicity? · Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology (peer-reviewed), via PubMed
  4. Acne: Tips for managing · American Academy of Dermatology (AAD)
  5. Cosmetics Labeling Guide · U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)

This page summarizes publicly available information from the sources listed above and is for educational use only. It is not medical advice. App names are trademarks of their owners, and Glow is not affiliated with them.

One selfie. A plan for your skin and colors.

Skinn (formerly Glow) turns one face scan into a skin score, notes for each area, a morning and evening routine, and a 12-season color analysis. Scan a product barcode for a 0-100 ingredient score. Free to download on iOS.

Download on the App Store