Skinn

Ingredients

Butylphenyl Methylpropional (Lilial): Ban, Risks & Labels

Butylphenyl methylpropional (Lilial) is a lily-scented fragrance ingredient that the EU banned in cosmetics from 1 March 2022 as toxic to reproduction. It still shows up in old and imported stock.

Last reviewed

The Glow angle

Lilial is the second most flagged low-safety ingredient in Glow's catalog of 35,000 products, mostly in older formulas and products sold outside the EU. Glow's ingredient scanner recognizes butylphenyl methylpropional and its other names and lowers the product's safety score, so you can spot it in old stock or imports. The score is a cosmetic safety guide, not a medical assessment.

Butylphenyl methylpropional (Lilial) is a synthetic fragrance ingredient with a lily-of-the-valley scent. The European Union banned it in all cosmetic products from 1 March 2022, after it was classified as toxic to reproduction (CMR category 1B). Great Britain followed later in 2022. You can still find Lilial on labels of older products, products made for markets without a ban, and some imports sold online.

Lilial is the second most flagged low-safety ingredient in Glow's catalog of 35,000 products. Most of those listings are older formulas or products sold outside the EU, which is why the ingredient still matters to shoppers.

What butylphenyl methylpropional (Lilial) is

Lilial is the trade name for butylphenyl methylpropional, an aldehyde made in a lab. It gives a fresh, floral, lily note, and for decades it was a common building block in perfumes, body lotions, shampoos, deodorants, and detergents.

On a cosmetic label you will usually see the INCI name. Other names include:

  1. Butylphenyl methylpropional (INCI name)
  2. Lilial
  3. BMHCA or p-BMHCA (butylphenyl methylhydrocinnamaldehyde)
  4. 2-(4-tert-butylbenzyl)propionaldehyde (chemical name)
  5. CAS number 80-54-6

Before the ban, Lilial was also one of the 26 fragrance allergens that EU rules required brands to name on the label above set levels. So it was already known as a skin sensitizer before the reproductive concerns.

Why the EU banned Lilial

The ban came from two lines of evidence.

Reproductive toxicity

Animal studies showed effects on the male reproductive system in rats. Based on that data, the EU classified butylphenyl methylpropional as toxic to reproduction, category 1B, under its chemical classification rules. EU cosmetics law bans CMR category 1B substances by default unless a narrow exemption applies. Lilial did not get one.

Combined exposure

The EU's Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) reviewed Lilial several times. In its final 2019 opinion, the SCCS found that each product type on its own could be considered safe at the proposed levels. When people use many scented products together, though, the combined exposure could not be considered safe. The SCCS also noted extra exposure from household products such as detergents and cleaners.

The animal data came from high doses, and nobody has shown that a single bottle of lotion causes harm. The ban is a precautionary rule based on the CMR classification and on total daily exposure from many products.

When the Lilial ban took effect

Here are the key dates.

  1. On 29 October 2021, the EU adopted Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1902, which added butylphenyl methylpropional to Annex II, the list of banned cosmetic substances.
  2. From 1 March 2022, the ban applied in the EU and in Northern Ireland.
  3. From 15 October 2022, products with Lilial could no longer be placed on the market in Great Britain.
  4. From 15 December 2022, retailers in Great Britain had to remove remaining stock from shelves.

The EU ban covers cosmetics only. Other product types, such as detergents, fall under different rules.

Where Lilial still appears

The ban stopped new EU and UK sales, but Lilial did not disappear from homes and shopping carts. Common places to find it include:

  1. Old products in your bathroom cabinet that you bought before 2022
  2. Perfumes and body sprays bought abroad or carried home from travel
  3. Products made for markets without the same ban, including some in North America and Asia
  4. Imports and resellers on online marketplaces
  5. Discount and clearance stores that sell old inventory

Outside the EU and UK, the rules differ. Some countries have no specific ban, so a brand can still legally use Lilial in products made for those markets. If you shop online, the same product name can have different formulas in different countries.

How to check your products for Lilial

Finding Lilial takes about a minute per product.

  1. Turn the product over and find the ingredient list.
  2. Look near the end of the list, where fragrance allergens usually appear after parfum or fragrance.
  3. Search for "butylphenyl methylpropional" or "Lilial".
  4. If the list shows only "fragrance" or "parfum," check the brand's website or contact the brand.
  5. If you find it, stop using the product and dispose of it as your local rules for cosmetics allow.

A product label that lists only "fragrance" can still contain Lilial in markets where brands do not need to name individual fragrance allergens. In the EU and UK, its presence would breach the ban.

Should you worry about past use?

If you used a lotion or perfume with Lilial for years, the risk to you is likely very small. The classification came from high-dose animal studies, and regulators acted mainly on the total exposure from many products together. Stopping use is a sensible step, and there is no need for panic.

Lilial can also cause allergic contact dermatitis. If you notice an itchy rash where you applied a scented product, stop the product and see a dermatologist. Patch testing can show whether a fragrance ingredient causes the reaction.

If you are pregnant or trying to conceive and have questions about past exposure, talk to your doctor.

Butylphenyl methylpropional (Lilial), in short

Butylphenyl methylpropional (Lilial) is a lily-scented fragrance ingredient that the EU banned in cosmetics from 1 March 2022 because of its classification as toxic to reproduction. Great Britain finished its phase-out by 15 December 2022. Check older products, travel purchases, and online imports for "butylphenyl methylpropional" or "Lilial," and replace any you find with a newer formula.

Ingredients to flag

Glow surfaces these on labels at the shelf.

  • Butylphenyl methylpropional

    The INCI name you will see on labels. Banned in EU cosmetics from 1 March 2022 as toxic to reproduction (CMR category 1B).

  • Lilial

    The trade name for the same lily-scented aldehyde. Some product descriptions and fragrance notes still use it.

  • BMHCA or p-BMHCA

    Short for butylphenyl methylhydrocinnamaldehyde, the name EU safety opinions use.

  • 2-(4-tert-butylbenzyl)propionaldehyde (CAS 80-54-6)

    The chemical name and CAS number in the EU ban regulation and on safety data sheets.

  • Parfum or fragrance with no allergen list

    Outside the EU and UK, brands do not always name individual fragrance allergens, so Lilial can hide behind 'fragrance'.

  • Products bought before 2022

    Older lotions, perfumes, and shampoos made before the ban can still contain Lilial.

  • Imports and online marketplace listings

    Products made for markets without a ban can reach EU and UK buyers through resellers and imports.

Frequently asked questions

  • The EU classified butylphenyl methylpropional as toxic to reproduction (CMR category 1B) based on animal studies, and EU cosmetics law bans CMR 1B substances by default. The SCCS also found that combined exposure from many scented products could not be considered safe.

  • The ban applied from 1 March 2022 in the EU and Northern Ireland. It came from Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1902, adopted on 29 October 2021.

  • Yes. In Great Britain, products with Lilial could not be placed on the market from 15 October 2022, and remaining stock had to leave shelves by 15 December 2022.

  • The US does not have the same specific ban as the EU and UK, so some products made for the US market can still contain it. Check the ingredient list or contact the brand if the label shows only 'fragrance'.

  • Stop using it and replace it with a newer formula. The risk from past use is likely small, because the ban is precautionary and based on high-dose animal data and total exposure. If you have a rash or are pregnant and worried, talk to a doctor.

  • Yes. Before the ban, Lilial was one of the 26 fragrance allergens that EU rules required brands to name on labels above set levels. It can cause allergic contact dermatitis in some people.

Sources

  1. Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1902 amending Annexes II, III and V to Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 (CMR substances) · EUR-Lex, Official Journal of the European Union
  2. SCCS Opinion on the safety of Butylphenyl methylpropional (p-BMHCA) in cosmetic products, Submission II (SCCS/1591/17) · European Commission, Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety
  3. Lilial ingredient ban comes into force in Great Britain · Cosmetics Business
  4. Allergens in Cosmetics · U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)

This page summarizes publicly available information from the sources listed above and is for educational use only. It is not medical advice. App names are trademarks of their owners, and Glow is not affiliated with them.

One selfie. A plan for your skin and colors.

Skinn (formerly Glow) turns one face scan into a skin score, notes for each area, a morning and evening routine, and a 12-season color analysis. Scan a product barcode for a 0-100 ingredient score. Free to download on iOS.

Download on the App Store